Bretha

The court · Bretha Étgid, “Judgments of Inadvertence”, the 7th and 8th centuries

The Smith’s Forge

A boy creeps up to a smith at work and is burned. Does the smith pay?

Basis. Rests on Kelly’s account of the law, not on the Old Irish text itself. Open questions are set out below.

Topics: Injury, Accidents.

The scene Our telling

Donnchad had been at the anvil since dawn. His arms ached, the iron was at its best heat, and he kept his eyes on it. He worked hard because there was a great deal to finish, and a bar cooled quickly.

Cormac crept in, close enough to touch the bar. He had wanted to see the red of it up close. A spark leapt, and the boy cried out and ran to his mother, holding his arm. Donnchad stood with the hammer in his hand and a sick feeling in his chest. Out in the lane, people were already turning to look at the smithy door, and at him.

A bearded smith in a leather apron hammers a glowing bar on an anvil beside a forge with a bellows. A boy in a green tunic steps back from the sparks, holding his burned arm, and a woman in a blue dress reaches out to him.
Donnchad at the anvil, and the boy who came too near.

What would you decide?

Answer first, then read the law. Your first answer is the one kept. It is stored only on this device.

On Kelly’s reading of the line about the anvil, does Donnchad owe Cormac’s family compensation?

Read the law, the commentary and the sources

The law

The law, as Kelly gives itBretha Étgid is the main source for the early Irish law of accidents. Kelly says it describes each accident only very briefly, though it is usually clear what is meant. Its section on accidental injury is a section on “immunity from liability”, cases where the person who caused the harm does not pay.

NoteImmunity here means that the person who caused the harm owes nothing.

The law, as Kelly gives itOne line reads, “the immunity of hammers is an anvil”. Kelly presumes it means nobody pays when a person is killed or hurt after going too close to a smith at work. He lists the same for harm from a flail at a drying kiln, a flying chip during carpentry, and a mill while it is milling.

NoteKelly gives no reason for the anvil rule. For travellers in a ferry and people at a fair he says the law treats them as having chosen the risk, but he does not say this of the smith.

The law, as Kelly gives itThere was liability, though, where a tool had a defect that had not been announced to those nearby. Kelly’s examples are a hammer without its bolt and a billhook without its rivet, whose heads might fly off and hit a bystander. His reference for this is one of the Triads of Ireland, number 172, and not Bretha Étgid.

NoteThe test in Kelly’s account is whether the defect had been announced to those nearby. He does not say whether the owner knew of it.

The commentary

Scholars sayThe old English translation, in the Ancient Laws of Ireland (volume 3), calls this text Lebar Aicle, “the book of Aicill”, a title Kelly calls incorrect. Binchy suggested that a group of texts, which includes Bretha Étgid, comes from a “poetico-legal” school concerned with the rights and duties of men of art, especially poets. Kelly adds that there is some evidence linking that school to Munster.

Scholars sayThe text describes each accident very briefly, so Kelly writes “presumably” of his reading of the anvil line. The rule rests on his reading. The scene above is our own, and nothing in Kelly turns on whether the smith had warned the boy.

Where we are not sure

Scholars sayKelly says Bretha Étgid gives each accident only briefly and he writes “presumably” of the anvil line, so the rule rests on his reading. The word étged itself is translated differently. Kelly has “negligence, inadvertence”, McLeod “irresponsible acts”, and the glossary of the Ancient Laws, which the Dictionary of the Irish Language repeats, “criminality caused by sheer wantonness” (all three as Breatnach’s Companion reports them). No complete copy of the text survives. We have not read the Old Irish.

Where this comes from

  • Fergus Kelly, A Guide to Early Irish Law (Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies, 1988), pp. 149 to 150, the section on accidents, citing Bretha Étgid at CIH 267.2 (the anvil) and CIH 273.29, 275.1 and 287.1, and Triad 172 for the faulty tool; p. 246 on the school of the text, and Appendix 1, no. 33.
  • The Old Irish text we have not read ourselves; the rules above come from Kelly’s account of it.

Last checked against these books: 2026-10-06. How we read our sources · Corrections