Bretha

The court · The law of killing, as Kelly and Charles-Edwards set out the law-texts, law-texts of the 7th and 8th centuries

The Body-Fine

A free man is killed. Who is paid, and by whom?

Basis. Rests on Kelly’s account of the law, not on the Old Irish text itself. Open questions are set out below.

Topics: Injury, Kin.

The scene Our telling

Fachtna was killed at the ford on a market morning, in a quarrel that began over nothing. His brother carried him home across his shoulders. By evening the news had gone up the valley, and his father’s cousins came, and then his mother’s people from the next glen, and they sat in a ring about the hearth.

No one spoke of payment that night. The killer’s kin had not sent word yet, and everyone in the ring knew who was close to Fachtna and who was only counted so. His mother sat with her hands in her lap. His brother kept looking at the door.

Inside a round wattle house, eight men and women sit in a ring about a hearth of stones with a small fire. A cloak, a round shield and a spear hang on the wall. A ninth, a young man on a stool by the open door, looks out at a river ford with stepping stones.
Fachtna’s kin about the hearth.

What would you decide?

Answer first, then read the law. Your first answer is the one kept. It is stored only on this device.

Who receives the éraic of seven cumals?

Read the law, the commentary and the sources

The law

The law, as Kelly and Charles-Edwards give itKelly says it seems that two main kinds of fine were normally paid for the illegal killing of a freeman. The first was a fixed body-fine, the éraic, of seven cumals, whatever the dead man’s rank. It went in full to the victim’s kin-group, the derbfine: the descendants through the male line of one great-grandfather. If a lord or other powerful person had to enforce the payment, he could take a third of it.

NoteThe sum was the same for every freeman, so rank did not change it.

The law, as Kelly and Charles-Edwards give itThe second was based on honour-price and was shared among the victim’s paternal and maternal kin. Each kinsman received a share according to how close he was. A man had full payment, presumably of his own honour-price, for the killing of his father or mother, half for a paternal uncle or maternal aunt, a third for a first cousin, and a seventh for a foster-father or foster-brother.

NoteThe more distant the kinsman, the smaller his share.

The law, as Kelly and Charles-Edwards give itThe killer’s own kin were expected to help pay. Where they were unwilling or unable, the victim’s kin could hold the killer until payment was made, by his kin or by someone else, or could put him to death or sell him into slavery. If a killer who had not paid was at large, they were obliged to take vengeance on him in a blood-feud.

NoteA killing was not only a private wrong. The kin were bound to act or to pay.

Scholars sayCharles-Edwards says the payments mark three kinds of kinship. The father’s lineage received the éraic. The mother’s lineage received a smaller fixed payment of its own, the “cumal of affection”, a single cumal. And kinsmen on both sides were paid honour-price one by one, each according to how close he was to the dead man. That honour-price depended on the rank of the living kinsman, whose honour had been injured, and not on the rank of the dead man.

NoteThe payments answer different questions: what the dead man’s lineage was owed, and what each mourner’s honour was worth.

The commentary

Scholars sayKelly says a killing of a person of high rank could be very expensive, since the honour-price payments are on top of the éraic, and that the killer’s kinsmen are expected to contribute.

Scholars sayKin-slaying, fingal, did not fit this system, in Kelly’s account. A killing was atoned for by payment to the victim’s kin, and kinsmen who killed the killer would themselves be guilty of fingal. The law-texts treat it with horror.

Scholars sayA later, Middle Irish text deals with a killing across the border of a túath, where the dead man’s king had to enforce payment through the over-king, who held a hostage for the killer’s túath. There the body-fine is divided. A seventh goes to the hostage. Of the rest, a third each goes to the king who enforces the payment, to the dead man’s kin and to the dead man’s lords.

Where we are not sure

Scholars sayKelly notes that no law-text deals with killing in full, and that the sources cannot always be reconciled.

Scholars sayKelly’s account does not mention the cumal of affection. Charles-Edwards takes it from an old text on díre, which says it is not subtracted from the éraic and is granted as a substitute for vengeance. Both scholars give the shares of honour-price to kin on both sides.

Where this comes from

  • Fergus Kelly, A Guide to Early Irish Law (1988), pp. 125 to 128, on illegal killing, the body-fine, shares of honour-price, blood-feud and kin-slaying; p. 12 on the derbfine; and pp. 175 to 176 on a killing across a border.
  • T. M. Charles-Edwards, Early Irish and Welsh Kinship (1993), chapter 1, pp. 23 to 26, on the structure of Irish kinship and the payments that marked it.
  • We have read Kelly and Charles-Edwards, not the Old Irish texts.

Last checked against these books: 2026-10-06. How we read our sources · Corrections