The court · Bechbretha, “Bee-Judgments”, between about 637 and 700

The Bee That Blinded a King
A bee blinds a man in one eye, and no one can say which of the beekeeper’s hives it came from. What does the law do?
Basis. Read in a published translation of the Old Irish text, with its notes and Kelly’s account. Open questions are set out below.
The scene Our telling
The man’s name was Congal, and the word that follows it, Cáech, means one-eyed. Something small struck his eye, burned, and then there was only darkness on that side. He never saw the bee, and no one else did either.
The law-text says that bees blinded him in one eye, and that the judgment given then was the first of its kind. He brought his claim against the man who owned the bees. The beekeeper stood by his hives with his hands spread. He could not say which of them the bee had come from, and nor could anyone else. Congal, with one eye left, wanted someone to answer.

What would you decide?
Answer first, then read the law. Your first answer is the one kept. It is stored only on this device.
The bee came from one of the beekeeper’s hives, and no one can say which. What does the law do?
Read the law below and find the line that decides it. Is it a rule you would have guessed?
Read the law, the commentary and the sources
The law
From the lawBechbretha is the law of bees. Its author cared most about two things: how a new hive fits in among neighbours, and who owns a swarm. Harm done to people by bees interested him less, apart from the case of Congal. He is keen to treat bees like trespassing farm animals, and he also borrows from the law on trees. The text covers theft of bees as well.
From the lawThe bees were not to blame if they rushed a man who was robbing the hives, moving them, seizing a swarm, or looking over the hives while the bees were swarming. They were in the wrong if they attacked someone passing by who was doing them no harm. Such a man was owed a sufficiency of honey, which Kelly reads as a meal of honey, if he swore that he had not killed the bee that stung him. If he had killed it, the law treated the bee as having already paid for its offence.
NoteA honeybee normally dies soon after stinging, because its sting stays in the skin. The law-text does not mention this. A glossator does, and he holds that the man is still owed honey, since he did not himself kill the bee.
From the lawIf a bee blinded an eye, lots were cast on all the hives, and the hive the lot fell on was forfeit for the offence of the one bee. Kelly says that hive became the injured man’s property. A gloss adds: one hive for a blinding, two for a killing. Sections 31 to 33 say this was the first judgment passed for the harm bees did to Congal Cáech, that the offence was charged on the man who owned the bees, and that it was the judgment of the Ulaid and the Féni. Section 34 gives the reason: it is one of the cases where a whole crowd answers for the offence of one, as when a carcase is found among dogs or pigs or cattle, or a man is killed in a crowd and no one can be named.
NoteThe editors set the lots beside a rule for a herd owned in common. If an animal is killed and the culprit cannot be found, a lot is cast on the whole herd and the animal it falls on is held responsible.
The commentary
Scholars sayThe editors, Charles-Edwards and Kelly, date the text from its mention of Congal. He appears in the annals from 626 and died in 637 at the battle of Mag Rath. The law-text speaks of him as having lost the kingship of Tara, which the editors think probably happened not long before his death, so the text is later than that. They read its language as a little earlier than the eighth-century Würzburg glosses and suggest about the middle of the seventh century, with about 700 as the upper limit. Kelly adds that outside Bechbretha there is no early evidence that Congal was ever king of Tara, and that most leading cases named in the law-texts are legendary, while Congal was a real person.
Scholars sayThe editors think a blinding bee-sting is unlikely but not impossible. The eye shuts very fast and a honeybee’s sting is shorter than an eyelid is thick, though venom might seep in. Kelly finds the case suspicious on several counts, and says that a single hive seems an extraordinarily lenient verdict. He notes that a later tale, Cath Maige Rath, has the Ulstermen first demand that the eye of the beekeeper’s son be put out, and makes the beekeeper the king of Tara. Another later story says Congal was stung as a baby, but the law-text implies he was a grown man.
Scholars sayLater commentary carries the lots further than the law-text does. Where there were many gardens, a lot was to be cast to find the garden, then to find whose bees within it, and then to find the hive. The text itself speaks only of the man who owned the bees and of all the hives.
Where we are not sure
Scholars sayThe editors call the blinding unlikely but not impossible, and Kelly says the verdict seems extraordinarily lenient and notes that Congal’s kingship of Tara is not confirmed elsewhere (the editors call it plausible). The editors also give two date arguments, one from his loss of the kingship and one from the language. The gloss about two hives for killing is late commentary, and the editors note the text itself does not deal with a death. One gloss says the man charged was the one “who owned bees nearby”, where the text has only “the man who owned the bees”. The source reports no dispute about the lots rule itself.
Where this comes from
- T. M. Charles-Edwards and Fergus Kelly, Bechbretha (Early Irish Law Series 1, Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies, 1983): the Old Irish text, English translation and notes for sections 27 to 35 and the dating. We read their translation, not the Old Irish.
- Fergus Kelly, Early Irish Farming (1997), pp. 156 to 157, on the blinding and the lots; and his Guide to Early Irish Law (1988), pp. 19 and 239, on Congal Cáech and the later tale.
Last checked against these books: 2026-10-06. How we read our sources · Corrections
The man’s name was Congal, and the word that follows it, Cáech, means one-eyed. Something small struck his eye, burned, and then there was only darkness on that side. He never saw the bee, and no one else did either.