Bretha

The court · Bechbretha, “Bee-Judgments”, between about 637 and 700

The Swarm in the Green

A man finds a stray swarm of bees. Whose is it?

Basis. Read in a published translation of the Old Irish text, with its notes and Kelly’s account. Open questions are set out below.

Topics: Neighbours, Bees.

The scene Our telling

Muirgius found the swarm hanging in the oak on the far side of the fence. He had no idea whose it was or where it had come from. He was close enough to the house beyond to hear its cock crow. The bees hung in a dark, humming clot, and the honey in them could carry his house through a hard winter.

He fetched a straw skep and stood under the branch with one hand raised, and went no further. Bees will not wait. If he walked away, anyone might take them. If he took them, he could not say he had asked leave of anyone, and a woman had come to the door of the house to watch him. His wife would call him a fool for hesitating, and he could not say she was wrong.

A man in a green cloak holds a straw hive under one arm and reaches up toward a dark swarm of bees hanging from an oak. A woman stands in the doorway of a round house. A bell on a frame, a cockerel on a post and a wattle fence mark the green.
The swarm over the green.

What would you decide?

Answer first, then read the law. Your first answer is the one kept. It is stored only on this device.

Muirgius has found the swarm in a lawful green, within a cock’s crow of the house. What is his share?

Read the law, the commentary and the sources

The law

From the lawA man who finds a stray swarm in a lawful green is owed a quarter of its produce for a year. The other three quarters go to the owner of the green. A lawful green extends as far as the sound of a bell or the crowing of a cock.

NoteA lawful green is the land close to a farmhouse, marked out by how far a bell or a cock can be heard. The finder’s share changes with the kind of ground: a quarter in the green, a third beyond it. A later gloss takes the bell to be a church’s, and the cock to be that of a hospitaller or a poet.

From the lawIf the finder comes upon a tree with bees in a lawful green, and the bees have been there more than a year, he has half and the owner of the green has half. The editors read this as an exception to the quarter rule, and a gloss says it penalises the owner for not walking round his green.

From the lawIf the swarm is found outside the green, up to a great forest, inaccessible country or unshared land, the finder has a third and the owner of the land two thirds. A swarm found in a great forest, in unshared land or in inaccessible country belongs to the finder, apart from a share to the head of his kin and a share to the church to which he makes a bequest. Kelly reads each of those two shares as a ninth of the honey.

NoteIn forest, unshared land and inaccessible country the swarm is the finder’s. The text calls this one of the complete immunities in Irish law, and keeps the two shares for the head of his kin and the church.

From the lawWhere there are many hives and a swarm has escaped from each, and a swarm settles on a neighbour’s land that is near to them all, and no one swears it was his, the owners share half of its produce for three years. The other half goes to the land where it settled.

NoteThis covers the case where the swarm’s owner cannot be told (BB §45).

The commentary

Scholars sayThe text sets out cases one after another: a quarter in the green, a half for a tree with bees there after a year, a third outside the green, and the whole swarm apart from two small shares in forest or unshared land. Kelly says the finder and the owner of the land share “in varying proportions”, and the sources give no single reason for the figures.

Scholars sayThe glosses add details the plain text does not have. One gloss on the third says the book does not say for certain whether it applies before or after a year. A gloss on the quarter says it is for bees there less than a year, and a half if longer. We keep to the plain text.

Where we are not sure

Scholars sayKelly says Bechbretha §§46 to 49 deal “in great detail” with finders of stray swarms and gives the proportions as “varying”. The editors note that the glossators disagree: one reads the quarter in §46 as covering only bees there less than a year, and another says the book does not make clear whether the third in §48 comes before or after a year. The editors also call the first glossator’s view that the tree in §47 is a sacred tree “quite unjustified by the text”. The text gives each of the two shares in §49 as “one third from every third”. A gloss calls that a ninth, and the editors read it the same way. They point out that if the rule was ever applied it would have been hard to prove how old a colony was.

Where this comes from

  • T. M. Charles-Edwards and Fergus Kelly, Bechbretha (Early Irish Law Series 1, 1983): the Old Irish text, translation and notes for sections 45 to 49. We read their translation, not the Old Irish.
  • Fergus Kelly, A Guide to Early Irish Law (1988), p. 108, on a finder’s rights in unshared land, and p. 124 on finders of swarms.

Last checked against these books: 2026-10-04. How we read our sources · Corrections