Bretha

The court · Bretha Comaithchesa, “Judgments of Neighbourhood”, the 7th and 8th centuries

The Felled Oak

A man cuts down an oak that stands on his neighbour’s land. What does he owe?

Basis. Rests on Kelly’s account of the law, not on the Old Irish text itself. Open questions are set out below.

Topics: Neighbours, Trees.

The scene Our telling

Fiachra had wanted the light for his barley for three summers. The oak stood on Brónach’s side of the stream, and its shadow lay across his best field from noon until evening. One morning in early summer he took an axe to it, and by dusk it was down.

Brónach did not shout. She walked the length of the fallen tree, counted its limbs, and sent a boy to fetch the judge.

A woman in a blue cloak stands beside a great oak lying felled along a stream. A man with an axe stands by the stump and faces her, and a boy runs off past a patch of young barley.
Brónach and Fiachra at the felled oak.

What would you decide?

Answer first, then read the law. Your first answer is the one kept. It is stored only on this device.

What should the judge order Fiachra to pay?

Read the law, the commentary and the sources

The law

The law, as Kelly gives itBretha Comaithchesa lists twenty-eight trees and shrubs in four groups of seven, ranked by their worth to a farmer. The top group, the nobles of the wood, was oak, hazel, holly, yew, ash, Scots pine and wild apple. Next came the commoners of the wood, then the lower divisions, then the bushes.

NoteKelly notes that the list shows a good deal of botanical knowledge and leaves out few native trees.

The law, as Kelly gives itCutting a tree on another person’s land carried a penalty-fine that depended on the group: five séts for a noble of the wood, a milch cow for a commoner, a yearling heifer for a lower tree and a sheep for a bush. For a noble tree the culprit also owed restitution that grew with the harm done. It was a yearling heifer for a branch, a two-year-old heifer for a fork (a large limb) and a milch cow for cutting it through at the base. The main text does not give full restitution figures for the other three groups.

NoteCattle were the normal currency. A sét was a unit of value, usually taken as half a milch cow, so five séts would usually be about two and a half cows. Críth Gablach in one place counts eight cows as ten séts, which would put the sét higher, though Kelly notes that “cows” there may include younger cattle. So the sum is not fixed.

The law, as Kelly gives itSome trees were classed as nemed, meaning privileged, and cost far more. The fine for a nemed apple tree was twenty séts, four times that for an ordinary one. A glossator on Bechbretha says a tree growing on the land of a nemed person counts as nemed.

NoteThe price of a tree could depend on whose land it stood on.

The commentary

Scholars sayThe groups follow economic value. An old commentary names what each noble was prized for, the oak for its acorns and its woodwork and the hazel for its nuts and rods. Kelly notes that the text counts the kind of tree but not its size, so a small oak and a very tall one apparently pay the same. A later commentary, which may come from a lost text on trees, outlines a fairer but more complex scale that separates large trees from slender ones.

Scholars sayThe fine is set by the kind of tree and the kind of cut. Kelly lists a few small takings of wood that the law allowed on another person’s land, among them barrel-hoops, wood for a bier or a yoke, and enough brushwood for one night’s cooking. None of them would cover felling an oak for the light. The tree was Brónach’s.

Where we are not sure

Scholars sayKelly says the main text gives full restitution figures only for the noble trees, and that an old commentary differs from it in small points for the other groups (for a branch of a commoner it gives a sheep where the text gives a yearling heifer). He is unsure of the meaning of two tree names, idath and crann fir, and of spin. The size rule rests on his word “apparently”. He notes no dispute over the five-sét fine for a noble tree, and we have not read the Old Irish.

Where this comes from

  • Fergus Kelly, Early Irish Farming (Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies, 1997), pp. 380 to 388: the tree-list, the fines for damage to trees and the wood that may be taken, citing Bretha Comaithchesa at CIH 203.2 to 14.
  • Fergus Kelly, A Guide to Early Irish Law (1988), p. 144 on damage to trees and p. 116 on the value of the sét; and his paper “The Old Irish Tree-list”, Celtica 11 (1976). We read Kelly’s account, not the Old Irish text itself.

Last checked against these books: 2026-10-04. How we read our sources · Corrections