Bretha

The court · Bechbretha, “Bee-Judgments”, between about 637 and 700

The Neighbour’s Apples

An apple tree on one man’s land drops its fruit on his neighbour’s. Whose is the fruit?

Basis. Read in a published translation of the Old Irish text, with its notes and Kelly’s account. Open questions are set out below.

Topics: Neighbours, Trees.

The scene Our telling

The apple tree stood by Ronán’s boundary. Half of it leaned over Tadhg’s side of the fence, and every autumn the windfalls lay on Tadhg’s grass. Ronán had planted it as a sapling with his own hands. Tadhg’s children gathered the apples in their aprons and ate them sweet and bruised.

Neither man had ever begun a quarrel over it. But this autumn the crop was heavy, and the two of them stood on either side of the fence with the red fruit between them. Ronán thought of the years he had tended the tree. Tadhg thought of the grass the fruit fell on, and of his hungry winters. Each was sure he was the reasonable one.

A man in green reaches up into a laden apple tree whose branches hang over a wattle fence. On the other side a man in a yellow tunic gathers fallen apples into a basket, and bowls of apples stand on the grass.
The apple tree over the fence.

What would you decide?

Answer first, then read the law. Your first answer is the one kept. It is stored only on this device.

In the fourth year, whose are the apples that fall on Tadhg’s grass?

Read the law, the commentary and the sources

The law

From the lawKelly calls the fruit that falls on a neighbour’s land a notorious problem, and says Bechbretha treats it in an admirably fair manner. If a tree growing on A’s land drops fruit onto B’s land, the fruit is shared equally between them for three years. In the fourth year all of it goes to B, and in the fifth year the cycle begins again. The editors of Bechbretha read the case as a tree standing on a boundary with some of its branches over the neighbour’s land, and they think the rule concerns only the fruit that falls on that land.

NoteNeither claim is brushed aside. In three years of the four the owner of the tree and the neighbour share the fruit equally. In the fourth year the neighbour takes it all.

From the lawIf either of the two destroys the tree, he pays the other a half fine, set by the rank of that tree (the verb is a tentative reading by the editors). A separate paragraph deals with lopping, and says the fine is higher where the tree has sacred status. A gloss says this depends on the rank of the person who owns the tree.

NoteThe editors of Bechbretha say that on the face of it the solution is highly favourable to the neighbour, though it still gives some weight to the claim of the tree’s owner. The text gives no reason for the fourth-year rule.

From the lawThe text requires an enclosure around the fruit, apparently because of trespass on the neighbour’s holding (the editors mark the word with a query). The glosses add that it is the owner of the trunk who must make it, so that the holding is not damaged by people looking for the fruit.

NoteThe editors find the reason uncertain, because one word in it is obscure.

The commentary

Scholars sayThe editors of Bechbretha treat §§12 to 17 as a side-discussion of tree-judgments. Kelly thinks it possible that §§12 to 16 come from a lost text, Fidbretha. The glossators are unsure about some words, for example the reason given for an enclosure, so we follow Kelly’s summary of the rule.

Where we are not sure

Scholars sayKelly gives the fruit rule in three sentences and notes no dispute. The editors of Bechbretha say that the glossators disagree about some words. In §12 the word for the reason for the enclosure around the fruit is obscure and “uncertain”. In §14 the verb “destroys” is a tentative emendation. Binchy would read the subject of “deposits” as the fruit and not the tree, and the editors call that reading equally good. They also say it is unclear whether the higher fine for cutting a tree of nemed rank applies to the lower classes of tree.

Where this comes from

  • Fergus Kelly, A Guide to Early Irish Law (1988), the section on neighbours’ rights, citing Bechbretha §§12–13 for the fruit (Guide pp. 108 to 109). The half fine and the point on sacred trees come from Bechbretha §§14 to 15, not from Kelly’s paragraph.
  • T. M. Charles-Edwards and Fergus Kelly, Bechbretha (1983), §§12 to 16 and the notes.

Last checked against these books: 2026-10-04. How we read our sources · Corrections