Bretha

The court · Bretha Comaithchesa, “Judgments of Neighbourhood”, the 7th and 8th centuries

The Dog on the Neighbour’s Land

A dog fouls a neighbour’s field. What does its owner owe?

Basis. Rests on Kelly’s account of the law, not on the Old Irish text itself. Open questions are set out below.

Topics: Neighbours, Animals on other people’s ground.

The scene Our telling

Sárnat’s hound had followed her to the boundary stone and gone on alone. By evening it had crossed her neighbour Ailbhe’s meadow, and it had not been tidy about it. Ailbhe found the mess while he was walking the grass, and he stood over it a long while with his mouth set hard.

Sárnat came when she was sent for, red in the face, with the hound on a lead. She loved the hound, and it had slept by her hearth for years. Ailbhe had never said an unkind word to her, and that made it worse. Each of them wanted the thing over quickly. Neither could say what would put it right, and the smell hung between them.

This case has a picture, but it shows part of what the law decided. It comes after your answer.

What would you decide?

Answer first, then read the law. Your first answer is the one kept. It is stored only on this device.

What does Sárnat owe Ailbhe?

Read the law, the commentary and the sources
A woman in a blue dress leads a grey hound on a lead past a standing stone. On the grass stand a small churn, a bowl of curds and a round loaf. A bearded neighbour in a yellow tunic stands with folded arms before a round house.
The dog, the churn and the neighbour.

The law

The law, as Kelly gives itMost of Bretha Comaithchesa deals with damage to a neighbour’s land and crops by animals. Each farmer lodged a fore-pledge with his neighbours against trespass by his animals. In general the compensation was matched to the damage done: cattle that broke into meadow paid twice as much as cattle that broke into moorland or aftergrass, and grazing trespass in winter, when grass was scarce, cost more than in summer.

NoteA fore-pledge is something of value handed to a neighbour in advance. In the Guide Kelly says it became forfeit if the animals trespassed. In Early Irish Farming he says it guaranteed payment of the fine, and that in some cases the pledge itself was forfeit.

The law, as Kelly gives itThe dog that fouls a neighbour’s land is an exception, and Kelly calls its treatment exceptional. Its owner has to remove the dirt, and has to give the neighbour the same quantity of butter, curds and dough. In Early Irish Farming Kelly adds that the owner must also replace the contaminated soil.

NoteButter, curds and dough were everyday foods. Kelly does not say why these three were chosen.

The law, as Kelly gives itA shorter text on distraint, which Kelly thinks is probably later, gives a procedure for a watch-dog that has done wrong. The injured party lays a plank across the dog’s feeding-trough and gives notice that it is not to be fed until the fine is paid. If the owner feeds it anyway, he becomes guilty of a “human offence”, which carries a much heavier fine than the dog’s own.

NoteDistraint was the pressure a creditor or injured party put on someone to make him pay. Here the pressure falls on the feeding of the dog.

The commentary

Scholars sayKelly says the law clearly felt this to be a particularly polluting kind of trespass, and that is how he accounts for a rule so unlike the one for cattle. That is his reading. The text, as he gives it, states the rule without explaining it.

Where we are not sure

Scholars sayThe dog rule rests on one short passage (CIH 74.26–30). Kelly does not say what “the same quantity” is matched to; the faeces is the likely answer, but he does not say so. The watch-dog procedure comes from a text he calls probably later. Later commentary goes further than the text: one comment wants all soil removed that even the stench has reached, and another has the dirt replaced by a sod kept under cow-dung for a month. A note in Early Irish Farming adds that an owner who saw the dog do it and did nothing seems to have owed the heavier “human” penalty. Kelly also reports, among the rules for dogs that injure people, that an offence by a dog straying by day counts as a “human offence”, because a dog should be tied up or on a leash at that time. Whether that would have raised what Sárnat owed here, we cannot say.

Where this comes from

  • Fergus Kelly, A Guide to Early Irish Law (Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies, 1988), pp. 142 to 143, the section on animal trespass, citing Bretha Comaithchesa (CIH 74.26–30, the dog), and p. 180 on the watch-dog.
  • Fergus Kelly, Early Irish Farming (Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies, 1997), p. 144, on the dog-owner’s duty to replace the soil and on the later commentary; p. 135 on the fore-pledge; pp. 140 to 141, 143 and 146 on fines in grain for hens and pigs; and pp. 148 to 150 on dogs.
  • We have read Kelly’s account, not the Old Irish text.

Last checked against these books: 2026-10-06. How we read our sources · Corrections