The court · Bretha Comaithchesa, “Judgments of Neighbourhood”, the 7th and 8th centuries

The Gap in the Fence
A neighbour’s oxen break through a poor fence and eat your barley. Can you claim?
Basis. Rests on Kelly’s account of the law, not on the Old Irish text itself. Open questions are set out below.
Topics: Neighbours, Animals on other people’s ground.
The scene Our telling
The wattle fence had stood for a year and a half, and a winter had left it thin along the lower field. Broccán’s oxen found the gap one warm afternoon, and by evening the barley was flattened. The owner walked the trampled rows with his jaw tight. It was the crop the whole house was counting on, and now it lay in the mud, half eaten.
He had paid for that fence in a lean year, and he had thought it would hold. Broccán came over the next morning and said the oxen were sorry beasts to have caused it. Neither man could look at the other for long.

What would you decide?
Answer first, then read the law. Your first answer is the one kept. It is stored only on this device.
Can the owner of the barley claim against Broccán for the crop?
Read the law below and find the line that decides it. Is it a rule you would have guessed?
Read the law, the commentary and the sources
The law
The law, as Kelly gives itNaturally, Kelly says, a landowner cannot claim for damage done by a neighbour’s animals if his own fences are inadequate. For that reason Bretha Comaithchesa describes in detail the construction and dimensions of the four legally approved kinds of fence and wall.
NoteKelly gives this as something that follows naturally, in his own words. In Early Irish Farming he adds that the text stresses a landowner’s duty to keep properly built fences around his land.
The law, as Kelly gives itA post-and-wattle fence must be built so that a small animal cannot get through it because of its closeness, and an ox cannot get over it because of its height and firmness.
NoteKelly calls the legal dimensions of fences in this text realistic.
The law, as Kelly gives itEarly Irish Farming names the four kinds: the stone wall, the trench-and-bank, the bare fence and the oak fence. The bare fence is the one of stakes and woven rods. Its stakes stand four feet high and about eight inches apart, with three bands of rods woven between them, and a crest of blackthorn along the top. The oak fence has the same measurements, with posts of oak.
NoteKelly calls the blackthorn crest the early Irish equivalent of barbed wire.
The law, as Kelly gives itSome trespass carries no liability whatever the state of the fence: cows in heat, rutting rams, bulling bulls and the like, because no fence could reasonably be expected to hold them. Nor is there liability where animals were chased onto the land by dogs or men, or frightened into it. And a farmer who deliberately breaks down a neighbour’s fence commits “human trespass”, which carries a heavier penalty than animal trespass.
Note“No liability” means the owner of the straying animals owes nothing. “Human trespass” means the law counted the harm as the owner’s own wrongdoing.
The commentary
Scholars sayKelly states the rule with “naturally”, as something that follows, and the text he cites (CIH 73.11–2) is the passage on the post-and-wattle fence. So the rule that an inadequate fence loses the claim is his statement of the principle, not a line he quotes.
Where we are not sure
Scholars sayKelly gives the rule without noting a dispute. The measurements are his reading of the text in Early Irish Farming, where he thinks it probable that the four kinds matched real farms fairly closely, though with more variety than the text shows.
Where this comes from
- Fergus Kelly, A Guide to Early Irish Law (Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies, 1988), p. 142, the section on animal trespass, citing Bretha Comaithchesa at CIH 73.11–2 (the fence); and p. 237 on how realistic the measurements are.
- Fergus Kelly, Early Irish Farming (Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies, 1997), p. 135, on the landowner’s duty to keep up his fences, and pp. 372 to 376 on the four kinds.
- We have read Kelly’s account, not the Old Irish text.
Last checked against these books: 2026-10-06. How we read our sources · Corrections
The wattle fence had stood for a year and a half, and a winter had left it thin along the lower field. Broccán’s oxen found the gap one warm afternoon, and by evening the barley was flattened. The owner walked the trampled rows with his jaw tight. It was the crop the whole house was counting on, and now it lay in the mud, half eaten.