Bretha

The court · Bretha Étgid, “Judgments of Inadvertence”, the 7th and 8th centuries

The Woodcutter’s Shout

A felled tree strikes a passer-by. Does the woodcutter pay?

Basis. Rests on Kelly’s account of the law, not on the Old Irish text itself. Open questions are set out below.

Topics: Trees, Accidents.

The scene Our telling

Diarmait was taking down an ash for his cart-poles. He worked the last cut quickly and did not call out, and the tree went over across the path where the miller’s boy was walking. It caught him on the shoulder. The boy lay in the leaves with his face grey and did not cry out.

Diarmait ran to him and knelt, shaking. He had cut trees all his life and never hurt a soul. The miller’s boy carried the sacks that fed his family, and now the arm hung wrong. The boy’s father came up the path at a run. Diarmait had not yet found a word to say to him, and the ash lay between them.

A felled ash tree lies across the grass, its leafy crown at the right. Under its branches a boy in a green tunic lies on his back on a path with his eyes closed, one arm across his chest, and a sack beside him spilling flour. A bearded woodcutter kneels over him with both hands held out. His axe lies by the stump among pale chips of wood.
The woodcutter, the fallen ash and the boy.

What would you decide?

Answer first, then read the law. Your first answer is the one kept. It is stored only on this device.

Does Diarmait owe the miller’s boy’s family anything?

Read the law, the commentary and the sources

The law

The law, as Kelly gives itBretha Étgid deals with accidents for which the person who caused the harm is not liable. Kelly names harm from a flail at a drying kiln, a flying chip during carpentry, and a mill during milling. He reads a line about the “immunity of hammers” as presumably meaning that a person hurt by going too near a working smith cannot claim. Kelly then adds that in some cases there is liability.

NoteThese are Kelly’s examples from the tract. He writes “presumably” of the anvil line.

The law, as Kelly gives itThere is liability when a tree-cutter fails to shout a warning before a tree falls and someone is killed or hurt. Kelly lists two other cases where the harm has to be answered for. One is a tool with a fault that had not been announced to those nearby, for example a hammer with no bolt or a billhook with no rivet, where the head might fly off. His reference for that one is Triad 172. The other is hurt from taking meat out of a cauldron with a flesh-fork when no warning was given.

NoteThe rule turns on the shout. Kelly records that a tree-cutter who gives no warning is liable, and he gives no reason beyond that.

The commentary

Scholars sayCompare the case of the smith’s forge. Kelly reads the “immunity of hammers is an anvil” as presumably meaning there is no liability when someone is hurt by going too near a working smith. A hammer with a fault that was not announced to those nearby is a case of liability. Kelly does not say why the law draws the line there.

Where we are not sure

Scholars sayKelly says Bretha Étgid “gives only the briefest description of each accident”, so some readings are his. He marks the anvil line with “presumably”. For the falling tree he gives the rule without noting any dispute. He does not say what the tree-cutter owes, or who decides whether a shout was heard.

Where this comes from

  • Fergus Kelly, A Guide to Early Irish Law (1988), the section on accidents, citing Bretha Étgid at CIH 274.17–8 (the falling tree), CIH 267.2 (the anvil line), CIH 273.29 (the kiln flail), CIH 275.1 (carpentry) and CIH 283.32–4 (the cauldron and fork). Kelly, pp. 149 to 150.
  • We have read Kelly’s account, not the Old Irish text.

Last checked against these books: 2026-10-06. How we read our sources · Corrections