The court · Bretha Crólige, “Judgments of Blood-Lying”, the 7th and 8th centuries

Nine Days’ Care
A man is wounded in a quarrel and cannot work. Who nurses him, and who pays?
Basis. Rests on Kelly’s account of the law, not on the Old Irish text itself. Open questions are set out below.
The scene Our telling
The blow came at a fair, over a debt of two sacks of malt. Ruadhán went down with his arm broken and did not get up. The man who struck him stood over him, breathing hard, still sure that the malt was owed. Others stepped between them, and nobody could say who had been in the wrong about the sacks.
By the evening of the fourth day Ruadhán could not hold a cup. Someone had to lift it to his mouth. The barley stood uncut, and the hearth went on needing wood. He lay watching the smoke gather in the roof, and he counted what each day of lying there was costing him.
This case has a picture, but it shows part of what the law decided. It comes after your answer.
What would you decide?
Answer first, then read the law. Your first answer is the one kept. It is stored only on this device.
On the ninth day the physician says Ruadhán will live but still needs nursing. By Bretha Crólige, what happens next?
Read the law below and find the line that decides it. Is it a rule you would have guessed?
Read the law, the commentary and the sources

The law
The law, as Kelly gives itWhen a man was wrongfully hurt, he was normally taken to his own home and cared for by his kin for nine days, doubtless with a physician overseeing. Should he die in that time, the man who hurt him owed the full penalties for a killing.
NoteMost sources give nine days before the physician’s verdict. One section of Bretha Crólige says ten.
The law, as Kelly gives itIf he was still alive after the nine days, a physician examined him. If he had recovered enough to need no more nursing, the culprit owed only for any lasting blemish or disability. If the physician thought recovery unlikely, the culprit owed the heavy fine called blood-lying of death. If the man would live but still needed nursing, the culprit had to take him away on sick-maintenance.
NoteThe physician’s verdict on the ninth day decided which of three outcomes followed.
The law, as Kelly gives itSick-maintenance meant taking the injured man in a set form, in front of three lords, to the house of a third party, probably a kinsman of the culprit, and nursing him there at the culprit’s cost until he was cured. The culprit and the victim’s kin exchanged pledges, and Kelly says a surety backed the culprit’s duties, though Bretha Crólige itself does not mention one. The culprit met the medical costs and the food and lodging for the victim and his retinue, and had to provide a substitute to do the victim’s work. If the victim was married and of an age to have children, the culprit also owed a further fine for the lost chance of conceiving.
NoteThe sick man’s house had rules: no fools or enemies admitted, no games, no shouting, no dogs set fighting, no children chastised. The text gives a long list.
The law, as Kelly gives itAn injury that did not reduce the victim’s capacity for work, action or movement carried no right to sick-maintenance and no additional penalty, only the ordinary payment for the injury. Binchy takes the additional penalty to be the kind fixed at the after-judgment.
NoteSick-maintenance was for injuries that actually disabled.
The commentary
Scholars sayBretha Crólige is one of the texts of the Senchas Már, which Kelly says range from the 7th to the 8th century and were probably brought together before the middle of the 8th. Binchy edited it in 1938. Kelly’s note says most sources give nine days, but one section of Bretha Crólige itself says ten.
Scholars sayNot every law-text agrees. Kelly says the compiler of Críth Gablach, writing about the year 700, states that sick-maintenance had already been given up in his day, and that the victim was paid according to his rank instead. An Old Irish passage quoted in later commentary goes another way: sick-maintenance is owed only where the injury was done through negligence, and a payment takes its place where it was done in anger. Kelly calls that at variance with Bretha Crólige. Ruadhán was struck in anger, so by that passage he would have had a payment and no nursing. Our question follows Bretha Crólige. Kelly gives the disagreement over sick-maintenance as an example of a general problem: such differences may come from a difference of date or of local custom, or from a clash of opinion between law-schools or even between lawyers in one school.
Where we are not sure
Scholars sayKelly says the texts are not explicit, but Binchy suggests that paying the blood-lying fine ends the culprit’s further payments whether the victim lives or dies. Most sources give nine days and Bretha Crólige section 41 gives ten. The third-party house is only “probably” a kinsman’s. Bretha Crólige does not mention the surety. Críth Gablach says sick-maintenance had been given up for payments, and one old passage keeps it only for injuries done through negligence.
Where this comes from
- Fergus Kelly, A Guide to Early Irish Law (Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies, 1988), pp. 1 to 2 on how the texts disagree; pp. 129 to 131, on illegal injury and sick-maintenance, which cites Bretha Crólige §§41, 42 and 59 to 61; p. 133 on Críth Gablach; and p. 153 on injury done in anger.
- D. A. Binchy, “Bretha Crólige”, Ériu 12 (1938), the edition. We have not read it ourselves; the rules above come from Kelly’s account of it.
Last checked against these books: 2026-10-06. How we read our sources · Corrections
The blow came at a fair, over a debt of two sacks of malt. Ruadhán went down with his arm broken and did not get up. The man who struck him stood over him, breathing hard, still sure that the malt was owed. Others stepped between them, and nobody could say who had been in the wrong about the sacks.