The court · Bretha Étgid, “Judgments of Inadvertence”, the 7th and 8th centuries

The Overloaded Ferry
A ferry sinks and a passenger drowns. Does the ferryman pay?
Basis. Rests on Kelly’s account of the law, not on the Old Irish text itself. Open questions are set out below.
Topics: Accidents.
The scene Our telling
Cathal’s boat took seven men and a pen of sheep across the river on the fair-day morning, more than it was built to carry. The morning was stormy, and the river was high. The men had stock to sell and a day’s trade waiting on the far bank, and none of them wanted to watch the fair begin without them. Cathal made his hard living from that crossing, and fair day was the best of his year.
Halfway over, the boat rode low and shipped water. One of the seven went into the water and did not come up again. His neighbours stood on the bank afterwards, soaked and silent, looking at Cathal. He kept his hands on the pole and said nothing.

What would you decide?
Answer first, then read the law. Your first answer is the one kept. It is stored only on this device.
Is Cathal liable for the drowning?
Read the law below and find the line that decides it. Is it a rule you would have guessed?
Read the law, the commentary and the sources
The law
The law, as Kelly gives itKelly says that a person who travels in a ferryboat is felt to have willingly taken on the risk of accidental death or injury. The boat’s owner is liable only if he sets out overloaded or in stormy weather.
NoteThe idea is that the traveller accepted the risk. That is Kelly’s reading of the rule.
The law, as Kelly gives itThe same reasoning is applied to a fair. A person attending one is evidently felt, Kelly says, to have accepted the risk of being killed or injured by horses or chariots, and there is no recompense for such accidents.
NoteThe ferry owner’s exception is setting out overloaded or in stormy weather. Kelly gives no definition of either.
The law, as Kelly gives itKelly’s other examples from the law of accidents run both ways. There is no liability for going too near a blacksmith at work (the “immunity of hammers”), for a flail at a drying kiln, a flying chip in carpentry or a mill while milling. There is liability for a tool with a defect that was not announced to those nearby, for a tree-cutter who fails to shout a warning, and for a person who lifts meat from a cauldron with a flesh-fork without warning. Bretha Étgid gives only the briefest description of each accident, he says, but it is usually clear what is meant.
Note“No liability” means the person whose act or tool caused the harm owes no fine and no compensation.
The commentary
Scholars sayKelly gives the ferry rule in a single sentence. He does not say what counts as overloaded or stormy, what the owner must pay, or whom he pays.
Where we are not sure
Scholars sayKelly’s reasons, that travellers are felt to have accepted the risk and that those at a fair are evidently felt to have done so, are his reading of the rules, not reasons he quotes from the text. He introduces the immunity of hammers with “presumably”. The ferry rule is cited at CIH 271.14–272.1 and the fair rule at CIH 265.41 and 283.28. In the old translation the tract was printed under the wrong title, “Lebar Aicle”, which matters to anyone looking it up in Ancient Laws of Ireland, volume iii.
Where this comes from
- Fergus Kelly, A Guide to Early Irish Law (Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies, 1988), p. 150, the section on accidents, citing Bretha Étgid at CIH 271.14–272.1 (the ferry) and CIH 265.41 and 283.28 (the fair).
- We have read Kelly’s account, not the Old Irish text.
Last checked against these books: 2026-10-06. How we read our sources · Corrections
Cathal’s boat took seven men and a pen of sheep across the river on the fair-day morning, more than it was built to carry. The morning was stormy, and the river was high. The men had stock to sell and a day’s trade waiting on the far bank, and none of them wanted to watch the fair begin without them. Cathal made his hard living from that crossing, and fair day was the best of his year.