The court · Davies’s Reports: the Court of King’s Bench in Dublin, 1608

The Case of Tanistry
Who takes the land: the dead man’s heir by English law, or the eldest and worthiest man of his kin?
Basis. Read in the report of the case itself, in the English translation of 1762. Its author was counsel for one side. The background is from Hans Pawlisch’s study of him. Open questions are set out below.
The scene Our telling
The old chief of the O Callaghans held the castle of Dromaneen, in County Cork, in the Irish way, by the custom called tanistry. After him it would pass to the eldest and worthiest man of the name, whoever that proved to be. But his son and his grandson both died before him. Then the old chief did an English thing. He settled the castle in the English form on his great-grandson, Donogh, and on Donogh’s sons and their sons after him.
Donogh died and left no son. A kinsman, Conoghor O Callaghan, came into the castle as the eldest and worthiest of the name, and claimed to hold it as chief by the old custom. He did an English thing too. He gave the land up to Queen Elizabeth, took it back by her grant, and passed it on. In time it came to a man named Brien Mac Owen.
The old chief also had a granddaughter, Eleanor. By the custom a daughter could inherit none of the land. By English law she was his heir. After she and her husband died, her son, Manus O Kieffe, entered the castle and made it over to Cahir O Callaghan, and Cahir put Brien’s tenant out. The tenant, Murrough Mac Bryan, went to law, and in time the case came before the King’s Bench in Dublin.

What would you decide?
Answer first, then read the law. Your first answer is the one kept. It is stored only on this device.
What did the judges resolve about the custom of tanistry?
Read the law below and find the line that decides it. Is it a rule you would have guessed?
Read the law, the commentary and the sources
The law
From the recordThis is not a Brehon law-text. It is the report of a case in the King’s Bench in Dublin, a court of the English Crown, which judged an Irish custom by English law. The report is dated Hilary term in the fifth year of James I, early in 1608. The facts in our scene are those a jury found, as the report gives them. One line in it is the lawyers’ and not the jury’s: that Eleanor was the old chief’s heir by English law. The castle, which the report spells Dromineen, lay in “Publicallaghan, otherwise O Callaghan’s country”. Murrough Mac Bryan was the plaintiff and Cahir O Callaghan the defendant.
NoteSir John Davies wrote the report. He was the Crown’s Attorney-General for Ireland, and the report says “the attorney-general” was counsel for the defendant. So the Irish custom reaches us as the lawyer who argued against it set it down.
From the recordThe jury found that the land had been held by tanistry time out of mind. By that custom, when a holder died the land was to descend “seniori & dignissimo viro sanguinis & cognominis”: to the eldest and worthiest man of his blood and surname. His daughters could inherit no part of it. The jury left the law to the judges. The report puts the question as whether “the title of the heir at common law, which the defendant hath, or the title of the tanist”, should be preferred.
NoteThe report has its own account of the word tanist, in a passage arguing that the custom began in violence. By “the antient Brehon law”, it says, the land went to the eldest of the sept, “the true tanist, and called in Latin, secundus, being the successor apparent”, and choosing the “most worthy” came in when stronger men pushed the eldest aside.
From the recordThe plaintiff’s lawyers argued that the custom was good law. Three things make a custom good, they said, “antiquity, continuance and reason”, and the jury had found this one older than memory. It was reasonable, because the eldest and worthiest man “can better manure the land and defend it, than an infant or a woman”. It was certain enough, because the law would take the eldest to be the worthiest. And if all that failed, the part of the custom that shut out daughters was still good, and the defendant’s title came through a daughter.
NoteTo manure land, in the English of the time, was to work it.
From the recordThe report gives the reply as what was “answered by the council for the defendant, and resolved by the court”, so Davies’s own argument and the judges’ opinions come to us as one. The judges, it says, gave their opinions at several times. They resolved that the custom was “unreasonable and void ab initio”, void from the start, because “a commonwealth cannot subsist without a certain ownership of land”. They resolved that it was “void for the uncertainty”: “some will say, that the most learned and knowing man is the most worthy; some, that the most valiant; some, that the richest; and some, that the most liberal: and so the multitude can never agree, and therefore the most powerful man was always preferred”. The report gives further grounds. The custom was “void against the king, as being prejudicial to his profit and prerogative”. And even if it had not been void in itself, “the introduction and establishment of the common law of England hath abolished it”.
NoteThe report does not hide what it thought of the people whose custom this was. It calls the custom “the true cause of the barbarism and desolation which was in all the Irish counties” where it was in use.
From the recordTwo more resolutions dealt with the two titles. The custom had been “interrupted and destroyed in the land” when the old chief settled it by an estate tail “according to the course of the common law”. And “nothing passed by the grant of queen Elizabeth” to Conoghor. He had surrendered the land as tanist, and a tanist, the judges held, had no estate that the common law would notice. He had nothing to give up, so a grant made in return for it was void.
NoteAn estate tail was an English settlement that fixed the line of heirs. An Act of Queen Elizabeth’s time let Irish lords give up their lands and take them back by royal grant, and the plaintiff relied on it. The judges answered that this grant had not been made in the form the Act laid down.
From the recordOne of the plaintiff’s lawyers argued that the land had been the Crown’s since the conquest, so that the old chief was an intruder on it and his settlement was void. The court resolved against that as well. Sir James Ley, the chief justice, said that where a conqueror takes the old inhabitants into his protection and lets them keep what they hold, their heirs have it “by good title without grant or confirmation of the conqueror”, so long as they hold it by the law he has set up.
NoteSo the court did not say that the Irish owned nothing. In its chief justice’s words they were to hold by the law the conqueror had set up, “and not otherwise”.
From the recordThe report ends without a judgment. The case “depended in the king’s-bench for the space of 3 or 4 years”. Afterwards, under a new chief justice, “the parties with leave of the court came to an agreement, by which a reasonable division was made of this territory amongst them”. The castle and the land in question went to Cahir O Callaghan. Both sides then took grants of their shares from the king.
NoteSo the men who had gone to law over tanistry ended by holding their land under English titles. The report’s own last word on it: “And so this country is well settled.”
The commentary
Scholars sayHans Pawlisch, who has studied Davies’s work in Ireland, says the Reports came mainly from Davies’s own cases and lean, as one would expect, towards the Attorney-General’s pleadings. He says Davies was careful to keep his own opinions apart from those of other counsel and of the court, but was not above using the Reports to press his own arguments, and that there is something of propaganda in their tone. This report is Davies’s own gathering of opinions that the judges gave at several times, and he was counsel for the side they favoured.
Scholars sayPawlisch sets the case in a wider plan. In 1606 the Irish judges had already declared tanistry and gavelkind void, in resolutions given outside any lawsuit. He notes that no record survives of how they reasoned about tanistry, and allows that they may simply have taken their resolution on gavelkind to cover it. The case from Cork was the first test of that in court. He says it is unclear why this suit was chosen, and suggests that Davies wanted the point tried before a jury more friendly to the Crown than one in Ulster would have been.
Scholars sayFrom manuscripts Pawlisch adds what the report leaves out, and says the people can be identified with some certainty. The old chief made his settlement in 1574 and died in 1578. The kinsman who entered as tanist was known as Conogher of the Rock, and his surrender and regrant were made in 1593. Brien Mac Owen was a McSweeney, and the plaintiff was his son. Cahir, the defendant, was an illegitimate son of another of the old chief’s grandsons. The quarrel arose in March 1604 and came first before the Presidency Court of Munster. The Court of Castle Chamber fined the litigants for forcing the sheriff of Cork out of the castle with an armed crowd of more than two hundred.
Scholars sayPawlisch gives two reasons why the ruling mattered. It made unsafe the title of every lord who, like Conogher of the Rock, had come by his lands by force. And it gave the government a tool against Irish titles in Ulster, after the earls had left in 1607. At Cavan in 1610 Davies told men who claimed freeholds that their chiefries had passed by tanistry, “which hath lately been adjudged no estate in law”.
Scholars sayDavies’s picture of Irish custom was disputed in his own century and has been since. Pawlisch notes that Geoffrey Keating condemned him for judging the Gaelic system by the common law and not on its own merits, and that Kenneth Nicholls has shown ways of descent that do not fit the Reports. Bart Jaski weighs the English accounts of tanistry, Davies’s other writings among them. Biased as they may seem, he says, what they observed is borne out by other writings and by the Irish sources, and “eldest and worthiest” sums up the customary rule well. He reasons that a tanist was next in line by custom but still had to be chosen, and could be passed over.
Scholars sayParliament did not do this work. Pawlisch notes that a bill against tanistry was drawn for the parliament of 1613 and never passed, and that the Court of Chancery was still hearing cases of Irish shared inheritance in 1622. He also gives the story a last turn. In 1631 the two claims to Dromaneen were joined by a marriage, between another Eleanor, the granddaughter of Conogher of the Rock, and Donough, Cahir’s son and heir.
Where we are not sure
Scholars sayPawlisch says Davies was not above using the Reports to press his own arguments. The judges gave no judgment here, and in what we have read their resolutions come only through him. We read his report in the English translation of 1762, and have not compared it with the original of 1615, which is in law French.
Scholars sayPawlisch, working from manuscripts, does not tell the old chief’s settlement as the report does. In the report it is made on the great-grandson, Donogh, and his male heirs. Pawlisch has it made first on a grandson, Callaghan, for his life, and then on Donogh for his. The family tree printed in the report has no Callaghan in it. Our scene follows the report.
Scholars sayBart Jaski mentions “the problems surrounding the ‘Case de Tanistry’ in 1594”, when he says an outsider claimed the succession against a boy of twelve whose descent gave him the better claim. That is some years before the lawsuit. Neither the report nor Pawlisch gives anyone’s age, or says who the boy was. Jaski’s reference is to Spenser and to W. F. T. Butler’s Gleanings from Irish History (1925), pp. 81 to 91, which we have not read.
Where this comes from
- Sir John Davies, “The Case of Tanistry”, in A Report of Cases and Matters in Law, Resolved and Adjudged in the King’s Courts in Ireland (Dublin, 1762), pp. 78 to 115. This is the English translation of his Reports of 1615, which are in law French, and we have read the whole of the report in it. The case is cited as (1608) Davis 28 and 80 English Reports 516.
- Hans S. Pawlisch, Sir John Davies and the Conquest of Ireland: A Study in Legal Imperialism (Cambridge University Press, 1985), pp. 34, 45 to 46, 69 and 76 to 83, with the notes on pp. 192 and 193. A modern study, read for the background to the case and for what came of it.
- Bart Jaski, Early Irish Kingship and Succession (2000), pp. 271 to 273, on English descriptions of tanistry. A modern study, read in part.
Last checked against these books: 2026-10-06. How we read our sources · Corrections
The old chief of the O Callaghans held the castle of Dromaneen, in County Cork, in the Irish way, by the custom called tanistry. After him it would pass to the eldest and worthiest man of the name, whoever that proved to be. But his son and his grandson both died before him. Then the old chief did an English thing. He settled the castle in the English form on his great-grandson, Donogh, and on Donogh’s sons and their sons after him.