Bretha

The court · the short text on distraint, the 7th and 8th centuries

Distraint on the Physician

A physician owes a debt and will not pay. What does the plaintiff do?

Basis. Rests on Kelly’s account of the law, not on the Old Irish text itself. Open questions are set out below.

Topics: Distraint, Debt.

The scene Our telling

Brígh was owed for a mare by the physician at Cluain. The mare had been her own, and she had sold it with her husband’s leave. The physician did not deny the debt. He said he would see, and then he went out on his round. She had sold the mare for a fair price and had waited since before the harvest. Her own household had gone short of the return, and she had stopped believing his sort of answer.

She stood in his yard and watched him go off down the road. The man had set her brother’s arm the winter before and sat up two nights with her sick child. She was grateful for that, and she knew it. Still, a mare was a mare, and he had not once said he would pay.

This case has a picture, but it shows part of what the law decided. It comes after your answer.

What would you decide?

Answer first, then read the law. Your first answer is the one kept. It is stored only on this device.

The physician still will not do justice. What does the law let Brígh do first?

Read the law, the commentary and the sources
A woman in a red dress and green cloak holds up a plaited horse-whip and a small lancet. A physician in a white robe, a satchel at his side, spreads his hands before a round house hung with drying herbs. Another figure in a red cloak stands behind her.
The whip and the lancet.

The law

The law, as Kelly gives itKelly says the short text on distraint also gives the steps for several kinds of dependent professional, called dóernemid. The plaintiff ties a withe round a smith’s anvil and tells him he must make nothing on it until he agrees to do justice. If the smith goes on working, his goods can be distrained in the usual way. A similar procedure is used for wrights, welders and workers with adze or axe.

NoteIn each case the formal step is aimed at the tools of the trade: the anvil for the smith, the horse-whip and lancet for the physician.

The law, as Kelly gives itFor a physician the formal steps are generally aimed at his professional equipment. The plaintiff carries off his horse-whip (the word may be a scribal change, see below) and his lancet. The text goes on to say that if the physician has no medicine-bag with him, the plaintiff ties a thread round the finger next to his little finger.

NoteKelly does not say why these tools were chosen.

The law, as Kelly gives itIf the physician refuses to concede justice after these formalities, he is guilty of evasion of a legal obligation, and in the end loses his honour-price.

The commentary

Scholars sayKelly notes that the text does not say what happens if the physician has a medicine-bag, which one would normally expect. Presumably the plaintiff would take it away or lay a withe across it.

Scholars sayIn a note Kelly adds that Binchy thinks the horse-whip in the text may be a scribal change for a word meaning a special staff carried as a sign of office. Kelly himself suggests that taking the whip may have meant the physician was barred from using his horse, which he compares to a modern doctor whose driving licence has been withdrawn.

Where we are not sure

Scholars sayKelly notes that the text “does not say what the procedure is if the physician has a medicine-bag”. He supplies “presumably” the plaintiff would take the bag or lay a withe across it. He also reports Binchy’s idea that “horse-whip” may be a scribal change for a staff of office, and offers his own alternative reading. He notes no dispute over the rest.

Scholars sayKelly says a woman normally could not sell or buy without the leave of her father, her husband or her sons, so we have given Brígh her husband’s leave. He also notes that the main text on distraint has thirty-three cases, with a stay of two days, that involve women or women’s work. Whether a wife would have gone to the physician’s yard herself, the books we have read do not say.

Where this comes from

  • Fergus Kelly, A Guide to Early Irish Law (1988), chapter 7, “Distraint and legal entry”, on distraint of the dóernemid, pp. 180 to 181, citing the “text on the forms of distraint” (Appendix 1, no. 67; edited by Binchy in Celtica 10 (1973) 72–86, physician passage at p. 83); pp. 182 to 183 on fasting; and pp. 76 and 179 on women’s legal capacity. Kelly’s notes place this text at about CIH 897.30 to 898.32; he gives no CIH line for the physician passage.
  • We have read Kelly’s account, not the Old Irish text.

Last checked against these books: 2026-10-06. How we read our sources · Corrections