The court · Kelly’s account of the restrictions on distraint, drawing on the Heptads and on other Old Irish material on distraint, the 7th and 8th centuries

The Cow That Had Just Calved
A creditor drives off a cow that has just calved. Is that lawful distraint?
Basis. Rests on Kelly’s account of the law, not on the Old Irish text itself. Open questions are set out below.
The scene Our telling
Senán was owed for a plough-share. He had given notice and waited out the days, and nothing had come of it, so he came with an advocate at first light. In the paddock he found the red cow, her calf at her side. He put a rope on her and drew her out through the gate. The debt was old, and he felt he had waited as long as any decent man could.
The calf kept close against its mother, still trying to suck. The woman of the house came to the door with her hands raised and said nothing. The advocate held the gate, a hand on his chest, and looked straight ahead. It was a cold, poor morning. Senán pulled on the rope and did not look back.

What would you decide?
Answer first, then read the law. Your first answer is the one kept. It is stored only on this device.
Senán has driven off the cow that had just calved. What has he done?
Read the law below and find the line that decides it. Is it a rule you would have guessed?
Read the law, the commentary and the sources
The law
The law, as Kelly gives itDistraint followed a fixed order, which Kelly takes from Di Chethairshlicht Athgabálae. The plaintiff first gave formal notice that he meant to impound the defendant’s property. A delay of one, two, three or five days followed, and during it the defendant could pay, or in some cases give a pledge. If he did nothing, the plaintiff could enter his land in the early morning, in the presence of an advocate, and take cattle to the value of what was owed.
NoteThe Old Irish words are apad for the notice, anad for the delay and tóchsal for the carrying off.
The law, as Kelly gives itKelly says the law set limits on which animals could be taken, with the aim of causing the defendant as little hardship as possible. The list includes a cow that has just calved, a cow due as rent to a lord or church, a bull during the time the cows are in heat, a horse wanted for racing, oxen wanted for ploughing, and pigs being fattened. Kelly’s list ends with “etc.”, so it may not be complete.
NoteKelly says the aim of these animal restrictions is to cause the defendant “the minimum of hardship or inconvenience”.
The law, as Kelly gives itKelly says the rules on distraint were complicated, and that a plaintiff who did not know his law could find himself paying the fine of five séts for improper distraint. Elsewhere he says the fine was halved where the distraint was carried out in ignorance. He does not say that the fine applies to each of the animal restrictions.
The law, as Kelly gives itIt is also an offence to distrain on a holy day, across a boundary except in time of war, or on the stock of a person who is moving house, unless he is a thief or fugitive. No son can distrain his father’s property.
NoteThese are further limits Kelly lists beside the animal restrictions.
The commentary
Scholars sayKelly notes that a wide range of livestock would be ineligible for distraint at any one time. But such animals might be distrained for their own offences, and he gives the shorter text’s mention of distraining oxen at ploughing-time as an example.
Scholars sayBecause the rules were complex, professional lawyers played an important part in distraint. Di Chethairshlicht Athgabálae says the plaintiff should get a man skilled in speech to oversee what he does. Kelly takes this to be the aigne, an advocate or law-agent, who received a third of the amount distrained (Kelly cites another text for that fee). The advocate was not fined for the “three mistakes of an aigne” if he acted in good faith. Kelly suggests the plaintiff would himself pay the fine if he had knowingly misled his advocate.
Where we are not sure
Scholars sayKelly gives the restrictions as a list ending in “etc.” and says they aim at “the minimum of hardship”. He notes no dispute about the cow rule, but gives no reason beyond that. He reads the horse of “a man who strives for the honour of the tuath” with “presumably”, and he says only “presumably” the plaintiff would pay the fine if he had misled his advocate. The passage does not say what happens to the calf. Kelly cites the cow rule by its place in the Corpus (CIH 38.19 to 21) and in the old translation (Ancient Laws of Ireland, volume v, p. 260), and does not give the number of the Heptad.
Scholars sayIn our scene an advocate stands by while the wrong animal is taken. Kelly does not say who would pay the fine in that case. The three mistakes for which an advocate was not fined are other ones: distraining where nothing was owed, distraining for a debt already paid, and distraining from the green of a noble who had power to protect the animal.
Where this comes from
- Fergus Kelly, A Guide to Early Irish Law (1988), chapter 7, “Distraint and legal entry”, p. 178 on the order of distraint and pp. 184 to 186 on its limits and on the advocate, citing CIH 38.19–21 (the cow just calved and the cow due as rent), CIH 897.15 to 897.20 (Old Irish material on distraint that stands before the shorter text in one manuscript: bull, horse, oxen, pigs) and CIH 359.34 (the fine of five séts in Di Chethairshlicht Athgabálae); and p. 151 on distraint in ignorance.
- We have read Kelly’s account, not the Old Irish text.
Last checked against these books: 2026-10-06. How we read our sources · Corrections
Senán was owed for a plough-share. He had given notice and waited out the days, and nothing had come of it, so he came with an