Bretha

The court · Di Chethairshlicht Athgabálae, “On the Four Divisions of Distraint”, the 7th and 8th centuries

Fasting upon a Lord

A lord’s cattle are driven across a woman’s land, and the lord will not pay the fine. What can she do?

Basis. Rests on Kelly’s account of the law, not on the Old Irish text itself. Open questions are set out below.

Topics: Distraint, Debt.

The scene Our telling

Muireann farmed her father’s land. He had left no sons, and the holding was hers for her lifetime. In the spring a lord’s herd was driven across her meadow without a word to her, and the grass was trodden into mud. The fine for that was five séts. She sent to the lord’s steward three times, and each time he shrugged, as if she had asked about the weather. She could not afford to let it go.

On the morning she went up to the lord’s house she took no breakfast, and she sat down outside his gate. People came and went past her, and looked at her and looked away. The herdsman stood by with the cattle. The lord might have known nothing of the meadow. Or he might have known all of it, and let his steward say no. That evening the smell of roasting meat came out over the palisade, and she heard the household sit down to supper with their lord. No one came out to her with a pledge, or with the name of a man who would stand surety.

A woman sits on the ground outside the shut timber gate of a ring-fort, an empty wooden bowl beside her. Two people look over the palisade, and an old cowherd with a staff stands by three cattle.
Muireann at the gate.

What would you decide?

Answer first, then read the law. Your first answer is the one kept. It is stored only on this device.

The lord has eaten while Muireann fasted, and has offered her no pledge and no surety. What does he owe now?

Read the law, the commentary and the sources

The law

The law, as Kelly gives itOrdinary debts were enforced by distraint. The creditor gave notice, then waited one, two, three or five days, then took cattle worth the debt and kept them in a pound. After a further delay there, they were forfeited a little each day if the debt stayed unpaid. Against a person of high rank, of the privileged class called nemed, the creditor first had to fast. This probably took place outside the nemed’s house, and distraint could follow it.

NoteKelly says the aim was to press a powerful person by moral force, since an ordinary distraint could not be used against a person of full nemed rank. The fine in our scene is the one he gives, in Early Irish Farming, for driving cattle across a neighbour’s land without leave.

The law, as Kelly gives itThe nemed was expected to promise justice by naming a surety or by handing over a household article as a pledge. If he ate during the fast without making any such promise, he owed double the original debt. If the plaintiff went on fasting after the nemed had offered to settle, the case fell. Kelly adds that a nemed who held out against a justified and properly conducted fast, presumably by resisting the distraint that followed, lost his right to be paid for wrongs done to him.

NoteKelly says that a nemed who lost his right to payment was in effect deprived of his legal rights in society.

The law, as Kelly gives itLater commentary allows the nemed a three-day respite after the fast before distraint is permitted. If the nemed has a substitute churl, the plaintiff must distrain the churl’s property, and he pays the fine for illegal distraint if he takes the nemed’s instead.

NoteFasting opened the way to distraint rather than replacing it.

The commentary

Scholars sayThe main text does not say how long a fast lasted. Later commentators take it to be only from sundown to sunrise, so that the main evening meal is missed, rather than a fast until death or settlement.

Scholars sayKelly distinguishes this legal fasting from a political hunger strike, though both aim to press a more powerful opponent by moral force. He notes that legal fasting is also known from early Indian law.

Where we are not sure

Scholars sayKelly says the text does not state how long a fast lasted, that later commentators take it to run from sundown to sunrise, and that it is unclear how soon distraint may follow the fast (later commentary allows three days). He gives “probably” for the fast taking place outside the house and “presumably” for how the nemed holds out. We have not read the Old Irish and the source notes no dispute over the double penalty.

Scholars sayKelly says a woman was generally without independent legal capacity. He names the female heir as an exception. Where a man left no sons, his daughter could hold his land for her lifetime, and like any male landowner she had the right to distrain goods. We have made Muireann a female heir so that the land and the claim can be hers. Kelly does not say outright that a female heir could fast against a lord.

Where this comes from

  • Fergus Kelly, A Guide to Early Irish Law (Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies, 1988), chapter 7, “Distraint and legal entry”, pp. 177 to 179 on distraint and pp. 182 to 183 on fasting; and p. 76 on the female heir. He cites the text at CIH 365.5 to 367.7 and Thurneysen’s edition (Zeitschrift für celtische Philologie 15, 1925) and Binchy in Celtica 10 (1973).
  • Fergus Kelly, Early Irish Farming (Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies, 1997), p. 138, on the fine of five séts for driving cattle across a neighbour’s land.

Last checked against these books: 2026-10-06. How we read our sources · Corrections