The court · Heptads 3, 51 and 52, with Cáin Lánamna, “The Law of Couples”, as Kelly sets them out, law-texts of the 7th and 8th centuries

The Wife’s Grounds
A husband strikes his wife to correct her. When may she divorce him?
Basis. Rests on Kelly’s account of the law. One of its heptads, on the wife who leaves without cause, was also read in MacNeill’s translation of 1923. Open questions are set out below.
This case is about a husband who strikes his wife. It gives the law as the law-texts have it.
The scene Our telling
Neassa had spilled the milk twice in a morning, and her husband Dubthach struck her once across the cheek in the byre, as he thought a husband might. By evening the mark had darkened, and she wound her shawl over it before she went to the well.
Her brother saw it at the fair on the third day and said nothing, but he walked home beside her. She had her bride-price to think of. She also knew what folk said about a woman who left a man and could not say why.

What would you decide?
Answer first, then read the law. Your first answer is the one kept. It is stored only on this device.
When could a wife divorce her husband for striking her?
Read the law below and find the line that decides it. Is it a rule you would have guessed?
Read the law, the commentary and the sources
The law
The law, as Kelly gives itDivorce was allowed for many reasons. Heptads 3 and 52 list the circumstances in which a wife could leave her husband and keep her bride-price, the coibche. They include his leaving her for another woman, though she could then stay on in the house if she wished. They also include his failing to support her, spreading a false story about her, circulating a satire about her, or tricking her into marriage by sorcery. Several sexual failings of the husband, and his being in holy orders, were also grounds.
NoteThe law gave a wife a list of reasons she could rely on.
The law, as Kelly gives itA husband could strike his wife to correct her, but she could divorce him if his blow caused a blemish.
NoteThe law allowed correction and fixed a limit at a blemish.
The law, as Kelly gives itA wife who left without just cause was “an absconder from the law of marriage” in Heptad 51. She had no rights, and no one of any rank could shelter her. Even a wife with good grounds lost her bride-price if she left before a recognised period of time.
NoteEoin MacNeill translated Heptad 51 in 1923. It lists seven kinds of protection that no lord or church has the right to give, among them the protection of “a woman who flees her rule of matrimony”, and it ends with a line from the Gospel: “that which God has joined in the beginning, let not man put asunder”.
The law, as Kelly gives itAt a divorce the property was divided according to the standing of the marriage, what each partner had brought into it, and the share of the household work each had done. Cáin Lánamna deals with this.
NoteNeither partner simply took what they had brought. Work counted too.
The commentary
Scholars sayThe law-texts allowed a husband to strike his wife to correct her. We tell it as the law has it.
Scholars sayKelly notes the severe line the law takes towards a wife who leaves without just cause, against the many grounds it allows a wife who has them. We do not know how often wives used them.
Scholars sayKelly points out how unevenly the Church’s teaching shows in these texts. Cáin Lánamna describes the procedure for divorce in detail without a word of condemnation, while the author of Heptad 51 quotes the Gospel of Mark against it.
Where we are not sure
Scholars sayKelly does not say what counts as a blemish here, or how a court would decide that a blow had caused one.
Scholars sayThe lists of grounds contain obscure items. Kelly leaves out one of them, a kind of husband whose name is unclear, and so do we.
Scholars sayKelly says the length of the “recognised period” that a wife had to wait is not specified, and that it probably varied with the husband’s offence.
Where this comes from
- Fergus Kelly, A Guide to Early Irish Law (1988), pp. 73 to 75, the section on divorce, citing Heptads 3, 51 and 52 and Cáin Lánamna §§26 to 33; and p. 2 on Heptad 51 and the Gospel.
- Eoin MacNeill, “Ancient Irish Law: the Law of Status or Franchise”, Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy 36 C (1923), pp. 314 to 315: his translation of Heptad 51.
- We have read Kelly’s account and MacNeill’s translation of the one heptad, not the Old Irish text.
Last checked against these books: 2026-10-06. How we read our sources · Corrections
Neassa had spilled the milk twice in a morning, and her husband Dubthach struck her once across the cheek in the byre, as he thought a husband might. By evening the mark had darkened, and she wound her shawl over it before she went to the well.